Inequality as risk: Davos 2014

What should business do about inequality?

Global patterns in income disparity between richest and poorest topped the agenda for global business and government leaders at Davos last week.

Expert respondents to the World Economic Forum's 2014 Global Risks report cited income inequality as the risk most likely, over the coming decade, to cause significant global disruptions, volatility and harm.

Many of the statements and media reports from Davos pointed out the (fairly obvious) 'business case' for paying attention to growing inequality: that at least for serious, longer-view businesspeople it is not merely a moral social issue but also a core strategic commercial  issue.

This is so both in terms of social and political risks, and opportunities to expand and deepen consumer markets. Very unequal societies exhibit distorted and uneven growth patterns, especially in terms of more broad-based demand. Especially for consumer-focused firms, the issue thus belongs not just to sustainability or CSR policy but to hard business strategy. In addition, as is clearly evident in parts of Africa today, as inequality becomes more tangible and visible it places governments under pressure. They respond by rolling out the sort of knee-jerk populist taxation and other policies that are anathema to business planning, rather than pursuing sustainable programmes to distribute some appropriate portion of wealth and to support those, especially the less privileged, who may seek opportunities to improve their economic status.

Conventional views would hold that the business of business in society is to help the economy grow, including by employing and taxpaying. It is then for government to redistribute some of the proceeds of growth in order to reduce any inequality that results. Beyond this basic role-division is the concept that if it is concerned about (the consequences of) insufficient action to address inequality, business can collectively lobby government to apportion taxed funds to doing so.

But what about a less conventional role -- business helping African governments not only to tax more effectively, consistently and fairly, but also to spend the proceeds more effectively in addressing social ills like income inequality?

At first glance it is assumed that businesses are not interested in having a more effective taxman. Yet in previous posts (especially here last May, also here) I have discussed the initially counter-intuitive idea that businesses can help strengthen their own regulator. Either by sector or in some other collective, representative grouping, firms with longer-term horizons in the region can and should explore ways to help governments build the capacity to assess, plan and execute social policy. Even a single firm (for example, the dominant mining firm in a single-commodity country) can do so: although this increases the risk of the firm 'capturing' the state, other institutions can be brought in to triangulate the relationship. These sorts of partnerships would at least give more meat to the rhetoric that public-private partnerships (PPPs) will transform Africa's economic and social development.

Last week's post on 'Africapitalism' reflected on the role of business in Africa in promoting inclusive growth -- not just calling for governments to ensure it.

Low or compromised state capacity in Africa impairs the state's ability to tax fairly and consistently, and to deploy and distribute those resources. In such settings it is perhaps not enough for firms to argue that they pay their dues and nothing more can thus be expected of them. It would be good (socially valuable) of business instead to look for ways to help the state make better use of taxed funds, including to promote programmes to boost incomes and income-generating capacity for lower earners and the poor. It would be smart and strategic for business to do so, too.

Jo

See an earlier post on PPPs, and on corporate responsibility and taxation -- including the view that strategic firms might help strengthen their tax authority: here.

The WEF's 2014 Global Risks report is here.

See for example this organisation dedicated to the role of business in addressing inequality.

Postscript: see Tobias Webb's post last week, also on Davos, and also on practical ways for business to help tackle inequality as part of a strategic approach.